Learn how New York penalizes disorderly conduct and behavior that disturbs the peace.
New York makes disorderly conduct a crime. Generally, disorderly conduct laws criminalize behavior that is likely to upset, anger, or annoy others. New York's disorderly conduct statute prohibits several behaviors, such as fighting, disrupting a meeting, or blocking traffic. The state also criminalizes similar behaviors, like disrupting a religious service, loitering, public intoxication, and riots.
Disorderly Conduct Crimes and Penalties in New York
Under New York's law, a person can face charges for disorderly conduct by engaging in certain types of behavior with the intent of causing public inconvenience, annoyance, or alarm, or recklessly creating a risk of doing so.
Disorderly Conduct Crimes in NY
Behavior that falls under disorderly conduct includes:
- fighting or engaging in violent, tumultuous, or threatening conduct
- making unreasonable noise
- using obscene or abusive language or gestures in public
- disturbing a lawful assembly or meeting
- obstructing vehicular or pedestrian traffic
- congregating with others in public and refusing a police officer's order to disperse, and
- creating a physically offensive or hazardous condition without a legitimate reason.
For example, getting into a loud argument with a friend on the streets of an otherwise quiet residential neighborhood in the early morning hours could be considered disorderly conduct. Peaceful picketing does not constitute disorderly conduct, but picketers who use obscenities or engage in threatening conduct could be arrested for disorderly conduct.
Penalty for Disorderly Conduct in NY
Disorderly conduct constitutes a violation. Although violations are not technically "crimes" in the sense that they do not go on a person's criminal record, they still can carry criminal penalties. A person guilty of disorderly conduct faces up to 15 days in jail, a $250 fine, and community service hours.
Other New York Crimes for Disturbing the Peace
New York also makes it a crime to disrupt a religious or funeral service, loiter, engage in a riot or unlawful assembly, and be intoxicated in public. These acts of disturbing the peace carry penalties ranging from a violation to a class A misdemeanor.
Crime of Disrupting a Funeral or Religious Service in NY
A person commits a class A misdemeanor by disturbing or otherwise making unreasonable noise at or within 300 feet of a religious, funeral, burial, or memorial service. This offense is punishable by up to 364 days in jail and a $1,000 fine.
Loitering Offenses in NY
New York law criminalizes loitering. An offender is guilty of loitering when they hang out in a public place without good reason to be there. Loitering under the following circ*mstances is against the law:
- to gamble, buy or use drugs, or engage in or promote prostitution
- while masked
- at or near a school, or
- at or near a transportation facility (such as a subway station) to engage in business or entertain people.
Loitering to unlawfully use or possess a controlled substance constitutes a class B misdemeanor, which carries penalties of up to three months in jail and a $500 fine. Otherwise, loitering is also a violation.
Public Intoxication Offenses in NY
Although public alcohol intoxication is not a crime in New York, police can take a person who is drunk in public into protective custody.
It is a crime, however, for a person to be under the influence of narcotics or drugs in public to the degree they may endanger themselves or other people or property or annoy persons in their vicinity. Such an offense is a violation.
Riot and Inciting to Riot Crimes in NY
A person commits the crime of riot under New York law by engaging in violent conduct with four or more other people and creating a risk of public alarm. An offender who urges 10 or more people to engage in a riot is guilty of inciting to riot.
Riot and inciting to riot constitute class A misdemeanors and subject a guilty defendant to up to 364 days in jail and a $1,000 fine. Riot is punished more severely if 11 or more people riot and cause injury or substantial property damage. This unlawful conduct is a class E felony, which carries penalties of up to four years' imprisonment and a $5,000 fine.
Unlawful Assembly Crimes in NY
An unlawful assembly is a meeting of five or more people for the purpose of engaging in or preparing for a riot. Unlawful assembly is a class B misdemeanor, punishable by up to three months in jail and a $500 fine.
Defenses to Disorderly Conduct Charges in New York
Possible defenses to disorderly conduct and related charges include constitutional challenges, statutory defenses, and failure of proof.
Common constitutional challenges in disorderly conduct cases include First and Second Amendment violations. Disorderly conduct charges based on speech, gestures, or displays could be challenged as a free speech violation if police arrest protestors or others whose actions don't rise to the level of inciting a breach of the peace.
New York law provides for several affirmative defenses in criminal cases, including coercion, justification, and mental illness.
Finally, like all crimes, a common defense strategy is poking holes in the prosecution's case. The judge or jury must find the defendant not guilty if the prosecution doesn't prove every element of an offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
Talk to a Lawyer
Although disorderly conduct and similar crimes carry relatively minor penalties, any criminal conviction can have lasting negative consequences. If you are facing a charge of disorderly conduct or a related offense, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney who regularly practices in your area. Numerous defenses may apply to disorderly conduct charges, and a qualified lawyer can evaluate the strength of the prosecution's case against you and help develop any defenses that might apply to your case. A lawyer can often negotiate with the prosecutor for a lesser charge or a reduction in penalties and will know how prosecutors and judges typically handle cases like yours.
(N.Y. Penal Law §§ 30.05, 35.15, 40.00, 55.10, 70.00, 70.15, 80.00, 80.05, 240.00, 240.05, 240.06, 240.08, 240.10, 240.20, 240.21, 240.35, 240.36, 240.40 (2023).)
As a legal expert with a demonstrable understanding of criminal law, particularly in the context of disorderly conduct and disturbing the peace, I can provide comprehensive insights into the concepts presented in the article.
New York Disorderly Conduct Laws:
New York criminalizes disorderly conduct, targeting behaviors likely to disturb public peace. The statute encompasses various actions with the intent to cause inconvenience, annoyance, or alarm, or recklessly creating a risk of doing so.
Behaviors Constituting Disorderly Conduct:
- Fighting or Violent Conduct: Engaging in tumultuous or threatening behavior.
- Unreasonable Noise: Making excessive or disruptive noise in public.
- Obscene or Abusive Language: Using offensive language or gestures publicly.
- Disturbing Assemblies or Meetings: Disrupting lawful gatherings or meetings.
- Obstructing Traffic: Blocking vehicular or pedestrian movement.
- Refusing Police Orders: Congregating in public, refusing a police order to disperse.
- Creating Hazardous Conditions: Generating offensive or hazardous situations without a legitimate reason.
Penalties for Disorderly Conduct:
Disorderly conduct is a violation, not a crime, but still incurs penalties. Offenders can face up to 15 days in jail, a $250 fine, and community service.
Other Disturbing the Peace Offenses in New York:
- Disrupting Religious or Funeral Services: Class A misdemeanor, punishable by up to 364 days in jail and a $1,000 fine.
- Loitering: Criminalized in various circ*mstances, including loitering for illegal activities, wearing masks, near schools, or transportation facilities.
- Public Intoxication: While public alcohol intoxication isn't a crime, being under the influence of drugs in public is a violation.
Riot and Unlawful Assembly Offenses:
- Riot: Engaging in violent conduct with four or more people, or urging 10 or more to riot, constitutes a class A misdemeanor. Aggravated cases with injuries or substantial property damage elevate the offense to a class E felony.
- Unlawful Assembly: Meeting of five or more people preparing for a riot is a class B misdemeanor.
Defenses to Disorderly Conduct Charges:
Possible defenses include constitutional challenges (First and Second Amendment violations), statutory defenses, and failure of proof. Affirmative defenses in New York law include coercion, justification, and mental illness.
Legal Counsel:
Facing disorderly conduct charges requires legal representation. A qualified criminal defense attorney can assess the case, apply relevant defenses, and negotiate with prosecutors for reduced charges or penalties.
Relevant New York Penal Law Sections (2023):
- N.Y. Penal Law §§ 30.05, 35.15, 40.00, 55.10, 70.00, 70.15, 80.00, 80.05, 240.00, 240.05, 240.06, 240.08, 240.10, 240.20, 240.21, 240.35, 240.36, 240.40.
